Commentary Track Oct 10 2008 @ 03:24 pm

Commentary Track - The Week In Comments

By Evan Derrick

omg are you serious?
Citizen Kane is the probably the best movie of all time
omg why are you all such morons?
My entire skins started to vomit after reading some of your review
I had to stop in order for myself to survive
I hate you and your family and anyones that even been in contact with you. Which probably includes me now but its worth it.

someonewhounderstandsgoodmovies on REVIEW: Citizen Kane…which sucked, by the way

I also think Evan, that was a great comment! And as to that ass “Flick Chart” what can you really expect from someone who spells Orson Welles’ influential masterpiece—”CITZEN CANE”
HAHAHAHAHAHA!!

What next:

Begone With the Wind?

The Six Commandments?

2003: A Space Odyssey?

No Country For Old Women?

Sam Juliano on REVIEW: Citizen Kane…which sucked, by the way

Mrs. Moviesetal and I collaborated on these. Shouldn’t Luke be playing too? What about Kristena?

Brunch at Tiffany’s

Hulu

Olivier!

The Wild Hunch

The Girth of a Nation

Run

Ed Would

Pattin’

Pleathers

The Mild One

Indiana Jones and the Temple of Whom?

Oceans 12…wait..Oceans 13…um…Dammit!

G on REVIEW: Citizen Kane…which sucked, by the way

I think the distinction that atheists such as myself would draw between Maher and Stein is the fundamental intellectual dishonesty we see in the latter’s arguments. Both films are polemics, and both rely on the smug style that drives the personality-driven documentary polemic lately. I think one can fairly take Maher to task for his attitude and Charles for his technique, but that’s different from saying that Maher relies disingenuous, spurious, or outright false claims, which is how I would characterize many of the pro-ID arguments advanced by Stein and his ilk. (Lest this erupt into talk.origins group of the twenty-first century, I suppose we can agree to disagree on such points.)

Andrew Wyatt on Religulous

The problem with the Zohan is that it’s not a truck we pushed, it’s a plance. It’s munitions plane that is filled with C-4, TNT and pipe bombs and the fuel tanks are full. So, instead of a funny cloud of smoke, the thing blew up. And Adam Sandler is gonna blow up as well if he doesn’t stop letting Rob Schnider book his films.

Back to Luke. He is not the movie police. Nor is he the Adam Sandler Police. He’s not even the Church Police. It’s not his responsibility to me or others to ensure that we only see quality films. He’s just a reviewer on a site for movies and he tries to do us all service by posting a review. While I am want to smack his head with a Zohan DVD case and then rub his nose in it like I would a puppy that whizzed onto the carpet, I will refrain and instead, thank him for being as honest as possible and trying to do what is right.

Maurice on You Don’t Mess with the Zohan

Oh, I’m sure their parents can. But how many are likely to take a stand on this issue?

“Yes little Johnny, the trailer for that movie has planted a song in your head so catchy that you are constantly possessed with an overpowering desire to see the movie. And all of your friends have seen it, and talk about it all day at preschool, and love their new Beverly Hills Chihuahua backpacks. But, as a cinephile, I have higher cinematic standards than you, and therefore deny you the right to see this movie, on the grounds that it is no good, even though you are too young to tell that. Just stay home with me and watch Criterion DVDs instead. You’ll love Persona!”

I’m sure that conversation would go great.

G on Theater Releases for October 3rd, 2008

One Response to “Commentary Track - The Week In Comments”

  1. on Dec 28 2008 @ 10:44 am 1. MompastReesHoibralip said …

    ajetjadvuyeumraewell, hi admin adn people nice forum indeed. how’s life? hope it’s introduce branch ;)

Trackback This Post | Subscribe to the comments through RSS Feed

Leave a Reply